Understanding Place: Rethinking How We See Rural and Island Communities

For the third seminar of the 2026-2027 Big Picture Thinking Seminar Series, we were joined by Dr Kirsten Gow, an independent researcher based in the Isle of Jura whose work focuses on rural and islands research. Over the course of the session, Kirsten took us through the limitations of how rural and island places are currently classified in policy and funding decisions, introduced the typology she developed during her PhD, and invited us into a genuinely participatory conversation about how we might do things differently.

Space, place, and whose understanding counts

Kirsten opened with a thinking exercise. Pick a place you know well. How would you describe it to someone who had never been? How would you describe it to a funder? And to a policymaker? What could you actually measure?

What quickly became clear was that we describe the same place differently depending on who we’re talking to. To a stranger, we reach for beauty, atmosphere, feel. To a funder, we talk about assets and opportunities. To a policymaker, we talk about neglect, distance, infrastructure. Each description is true. Each leaves things out. And the version that ends up shaping funding decisions, service design and policy is rarely the one told by the people who live there.

That gap, Kirsten argued, is the gap between space and place. Drawing on the geographer Tim Cresswell, she explained the distinction: space is a location without meaning – a set of coordinates, a point on a map. Place is what emerges when human beings invest that space with meaning: naming it, living in it, remembering it. A park on a sunny day with friends is a different place from the same park alone at night. Rural Scotland as a tourist destination is a different place from rural Scotland as somewhere you live and work.

The problem is that policy is usually designed from space, not place. “Those developing national policy,” Kirsten said, “may have limited experience of rural and island life beyond visiting on holiday or for work. And their assumptions about how these places function may be quite different from the realities on the ground.”

When urban is the default

Kirsten gave several examples of what happens when urban is assumed as the norm. On Jura, a new social housing development was required to meet planning standards set in Lochgilphead – double-width roads, pavements, street lighting. The streetlights attracted the deer, who ate the gardens. Everyone kept walking down the middle of the road. The developer confirmed that if those urban standards hadn’t been required, the money and space saved would have allowed for one extra house.

A proposed cycle path on Jura couldn’t be funded because national minimum standards required it to be three metres wide – wider than much of the island’s road network. The attempt to ban wood burning stoves in new-build homes ignored higher rural fuel poverty and the frequency of multi-day power cuts. Twenty-minute neighbourhoods, a planning principle imported from urban design, became unworkable in places where it takes more than twenty minutes to walk to a bus stop.

Each of these, Kirsten argued, is the result of policy that treats rural as an exception to adjust for after the fact, rather than a reality to design for from the start. “If your policy requires rural or island exceptions, it is, by its nature, an urban-centric policy. Truly universal design starts by including rural from the start.”

A different way of grouping places

Existing classifications – the Scottish Government’s urban-rural classification, SIMD, local authority groupings – often mask more than they reveal. When Jura, Islay and Colonsay are reported as a single unit, Islay’s larger population skews the figures. When rural places are compared by distance from an urban centre, nothing is captured about how a community actually functions.

Kirsten’s typology takes a different approach. Rather than grouping islands by location or size, she focused on two concepts: capacity (the resources an island can draw on itself – population, services, amenities) and reliance (how much it must depend on external actors, and how easy or difficult that reliance is to sustain). Using a decile-based scoring system, she developed seven distinct island types – from connected independent islands to reliant outer isles – that cut across geographic region and reveal patterns that proximity-based classifications miss.

The typology was taken up by the Scottish Government, and Kirsten went on to complete an internship there in 2025, developing the national Scottish Islands Typology.

What next

The approach Kirsten developed for islands, she argued, has clear relevance for how we understand rural places more widely. She’s recently submitted a major funding bid with Scottish Rural Action to create a similar framework for rural areas, and the conversation in the room – from Lochgilphead to Jura to Helensburgh – made clear how much appetite there is for a more place-sensitive way of thinking.

Resources

Kirsten has kindly shared her slides, and the recording is available via the link below. She can be contacted at: [email protected]

Up next: our December Big Picture Thinking seminar is on Thursday 10 December, 10am–12pm, when Anne Pordes and Julie Jenson join us for Collaborating with Communities: Facing Ourselves in Community Collaboration. Register on Eventbrite.